He's Not Your Kid


“That’s not how I did it, and my kids turned out fine.” Sound familiar?

Grandparent-parent tension is a frequent issue in therapy, says Irene Erckert, PhD, a psychologist based in Newtown, PA, and Lawrenceville, NJ.

Theresa O’Brien, MSN, RN, manages Parent Education at Philadelphia’s Thomas Jefferson University Hospital and oversees grandparenting classes there. She says quarrels between parents and grandparents often go well beyond generational differences in parenting practices.

Clashes can involve boundaries, rules, resentment, jealousy, styles, limitations, guilt, respect, beliefs or many other flashpoints.

O’Brien’s bottom line for grandparents: He’s not your kid; he’s theirs. Grandparents have a special role, but it’s different from that of parents. Grandparents can bring history, interpretation of experience, legacy, a sounding board, talents and support to the table — when it is welcome. Otherwise, unless there’s an emergency, “Silence is a great quality,” O’Brien advises.


Especially during the early months, O’Brien urges grandparents to give new parents time to bond with their babies and establish their own skills and confidence. Initially, grands can best support parents by performing useful chores such as laundry, dishes or shopping.

Parents of little ones are often sleep-deprived and not at the top of their game. They’re sensitive to what they hear as judgment. If asked, or if circumstances require a grandparent to comment, it’s best to frame remarks with “I” messages, as in, “I found this to be helpful,” rather than, “You should do this.”


What happens when the parents ask the grands to step in as babysitters? Where is the line between honoring the parents’ rules and overstepping?

Is it okay for Grandpa to allow two TV shows instead of just one? What if the rule is no electronic games on weeknights or no food in the living room? 

Is it okay to sneak such things as a “special secret”?

It’s essential to avoid putting children in the middle of disagreements, emphasizes Dr. Erckert. She urges direct communication between grandparents and parents, to respectfully — and privately  — discuss their concerns and reasoning.  Here are some keys to getting along.

• Will the grandparents honor the parents’ rules? Children can thrive in different ways. Grandparents needn’t feel insulted if their adult children parent differently than they did.

• Are grandparents being candid about their physical limitations, emotional stress and schedules? Do the parents understand that some grandparents sacrifice their schedules instead of saying no? Or that they might have difficulty with car seats or night driving?

• Do the parents demand too much of the grandparents or refuse their calls?

• Consider separate rules for the grandparents, when called for. For example, are parents willing to tell children that when Grandmom is in charge, there are no [electronics, trampoline or another area that grandparents might have difficulty monitoring]?

Special triggers

Grandchildren, of course, have individual temperaments and needs.

Discipline and food often trigger stress. A common scenario is a grandparent who resists a grandchild’s vegan or vegetarian diet and tries to push meat. Dr. Erckert, who also treats eating disorders, suggests that parents provide informative articles or invite the grandparents to join a session with a nutritionist.

Communicate to create a “collaborative resolution” in the child’s best interest, she advises.

Collaboration works best when parents and grandparents work flexibly together to solve problems. It’s more challenging if the parents and grandparents have a history of power struggles or poor communication, says Rita DeMaria, PhD, director of the Healthy Relationships & Wellness Programs at Thomas Jefferson University.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here